Weekly E-mails:  Crypto Trading Strategy 5 Weeks of Onboarding Reads. Latest Airdrops (Thu 7 AM EST). Or all of it.

Dismiss   Pick Your Preference
This site uses cookies (More).


About the proposed Ethereum ETF - #CryptoTrading

The surveillance section of EtherIndex's rule change (which after the Winklevoss' BTC ETF seems to be the key part) proposes a strategy which might be more plausible.
Blog, OpEd, Opinion
     · [reports]  · Author: @tradingfanbois

Image: The surveillance section of the rule change seems to be the key part after the rejection of Winklevoss COIN ETF. EtherIndex’s suggestion seems more plausible.

Update - September 2017

EtherIndex has withdrawn their application. Full document at sec.gov

After the SEC disapproved the rule change to allow listing of Bitcoin ETF on the 10th of March 2017 the majority opinion has been along the lines that other cryptocurrency ETFs most likely don’t have a chance because all cryptocurrency markets are unregulated. Nonetheless there is a nice twist in the rule change for ETH ETF - an idea that didn’t appear in the Bitcoin rule change.

EtherIndex - The ETH Exchange Traded Fund

The initial S-1 filling for the ETH fund appeared in July 2016 after the SEC opening a proposal for the COIN ETF for public comment and also right after a filing by SolidX to launch a Bitcoin ETF. Laura Shin of Forbes commented the “filing appears to be hastily put together”:

EtherIndex itself was only founded a month ago, and its filing is mostly incomplete, acting more as a shell or placeholder. It does not name an exchange, ticker, trustee or administrator. via forbes.com

The S-1 Filing

This is a snippet from the filing itself. It introduces Ether by comparison to Bitcoin.

As filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission on July 15, 2016

Ether is a digital asset (“Digital Asset”) similar to bitcoin that is not issued by any government, bank or central organization. […] The Ethereum Network is a recent technological innovation, and the ether that is created, transferred, used and stored by entities and individuals have certain features associated with several types of assets, most notably commodities and currencies.

The Trust’s Sponsor is EtherIndex LLC, a Delaware limited liability company formed on June 15, 2016.

via sec.gov

However, further down in the text it clears up distinctions between Ether and Bitcoin.

While the bitcoin network permits users primarily to execute value transfers, the Ethereum Network allows users to program any arbitrary code and execute it, including value transfers. […] The Ethereum Network may be viewed as a global, decentralized computer in comparison to the bitcoin network, which is more similar to a global, decentralized payment network.

via sec.gov

The filing also explains that as Bitcoin is meant more like a store of value it has a cap on the amount of BTC that will be ever mined. It goes on to say that ETH has no such cap and more Ether will be created as needed, but the utility of Ether is primarily not a store of value or a payment system.

The nonexistent cap has been controversial ans is also the reason why this moneymorning.com article claims that an ETH ETF can never work - it is supposed to be a bad idea since ETH has no cap on the amount of Ether that will be created.

The Rule Change

The rule change to allow listing of an ETF trading Ether shares was published in January 2017. The ETH ETF should be listed under NYSE Arca Equities.

Release No. 34-79792; File No. SR-NYSEARCA-2016-176, January 13, 2017

Pursuant to Section 19(b)(1)1 of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (the “Act”)2 and Rule 19b-4 thereunder,3 notice is hereby given that, on December 30, 2016, NYSE Arca, Inc. (the “Exchange” or “NYSE Arca”) filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission (the “Commission”) the proposed rule change […] The Commission is publishing this notice to solicit comments on the proposed rule change from interested persons.

The Exchange proposes to list and trade shares of the following under NYSE Arca Equities Rule 8.201: EtherIndex Ether Trust (“Trust”).

For the EtherIndex ETF, Coinbase is supposed to be the custodian and the pricing should be based on GDAX dollar price of ETH.

The Exchange proposes to list and trade shares (“Shares”) of the Trust pursuant to NYSE Arca Equities […] The sponsor of the Trust is EtherIndex LLC (“Sponsor”), a Delaware limited liability company. Delaware Trust Company is the trustee of the Trust (“Trustee”). The Bank of New York Mellon will be the administrator (“Administrator”) and custodian of cash of the Trust (“Cash Custodian”). Coinbase will be the custodian of the ether of the Trust (“Ether Custodian”).

via sec.gov (Release No. 34-79792; File No. SR-NYSEARCA-2016-176)

For one thing, the participation of Coinbase/GDAX itself seems to be a better idea compared to the Winklevoss Gemini - an exchange that doesn’t have much volume and was probably created only with the ETF in mind.

The interesting part comes with the Surveillance section of the ETH ETF rule change though.

If you didn’t care about the Bitcoin ETF much you might not know it but insufficient control over BTC markets (both spot and derivatives) was the most prominent critic the SEC mentioned in their order disapproving the COIN ETF.

Order disapproving rule change for COIN ETF: […] the Commission is disapproving this proposed rule change because it does not find the proposal to be consistent with Section 6(b)(5) of the Exchange Act, which requires […] to prevent fraudulent and manipulative acts and practices […]

[…] First, the exchange must have surveillance-sharing agreements with significant markets for trading the underlying commodity or derivatives on that commodity. And second, those markets must be regulated. Based on the record before it, the Commission believes that the significant markets for bitcoin are unregulated.

via sec.gov (Release No. 34-80206; File No. SR-BatsBZX-2016-30)

The SEC didn’t like the fact that majority of BTC trading occurs on exchanges out of their reach. Should a manipulation occur the SEC also wouldn’t be able to find out who’s causing it.

The surveillance-sharing agreement was a term that caught on quickly at Bitcoin trading forums. It quickly solidified into “the SEC wanted access to data about customers, exchanges didn’t want to provide it”. How did this surveillance-sharing agreement come about? It was the central point of the Bats rule change for COIN ETF:

Bats rule change / Surveillance: The Exchange believes that its surveillance procedures are adequate to properly monitor the trading of the Shares on the Exchange during all trading sessions and to deter and detect violations of Exchange rules and the applicable federal securities laws. […] The Exchange may obtain information regarding trading in the Shares via the Intermarket Surveillance Group (“ISG”), from other exchanges who are members or affiliates of the ISG, or with which the Exchange has entered into a comprehensive surveillance sharing agreement. In addition, the Exchange may obtain information about bitcoin transactions, trades and market data from Bitcoin Exchanges with which the Exchange has entered into a comprehensive surveillance sharing agreement as well as certain additional information that is publicly available through the Blockchain. The Exchange notes that it has entered into a comprehensive surveillance sharing agreement with Gemini Exchange.

via sec.gov (Release No. 34-78262; File No. SR-BatsBZX-2016-30)

Was it the Winkletwins’ idea that exchanges should agree to provide data so that there can be an ETF listed? There is no mention about surveillance-sharing agreement in the EtherIndex rule change. Instead, the exchange pleads to monitor the market and intervene in case there is an anomaly in the trading activity which could potentially be a manipulation.

Given enough data this sounds like a plausible way to detect manipulation while at the same time there is no agreement needed whatsoever: the market data are freely accessible.

NYSE rule change / Surveillance: The Exchange represents that trading in the Shares will be subject to the existing trading surveillances administered by the Exchange, as well as cross-market surveillances administered by the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (“FINRA”) on behalf of the Exchange

The surveillances referred to above generally focus on detecting securities trading outside their normal patterns, which could be indicative of manipulative or other violative activity. When such situations are detected, surveillance analysis follows and investigations are opened, where appropriate, to review the behavior of all relevant parties for all relevant trading violations.

via sec.gov (Release No. 34-79792; File No. SR-NYSEARCA-2016-176)

The rule change also states that price of Ether shares should be determined based on GDAX ETHUSD market but if the market will seem unhealthy, a Kraken pricing might be used. If Kraken is not available, it would be Gemini. If no big American exchange provides reasonable data, the pricing of Ether shares can be set manually.

[…] if the Sponsor determines that the Kraken Bitcoin Exchange and the Gemini Exchange prices are not appropriate bases for evaluation of the Trust’s ether, the Sponsor’s [EtherIndex LLC] good faith estimate of the market price of ether.

via sec.gov (Release No. 34-79792; File No. SR-NYSEARCA-2016-176)

Of course one question is whether there was a reason the Winklevoss brothers opted for the tedious and probably next to impossible route of surveillance agreements - or whether simply nobody considered this way. In the recent days Bats filed a petition for the SEC to change their decision and list the COIN ETF after all but even now there has been no change made to the proposal. And another question is indeed what will the SEC actually say to the EtherIndex suggested solution for the surveillance and control problem. We’ll have to wait for that.

Last but not least, one thing that could surely help the ETH ETF is the majority of ETH/fiat trading occurs in the US. Only very small amount of ETH/fiat trading happens in China and Russia.

Image: An illustration, not a statistics! Volume distribution across countries for ETH/fiat pairs in the top 20 ETH markets. Single day data only, via coinmarketcap.com. View as PDF

After all, from a legacy investor point of view it does not make such a fundamental difference whether to invest in Bitcoin or in Ether. The two currencies trade like competitors, very often they are inversely correlated, while both of them are equally uncorrelated with all of the legacy markets.

One more important detail

Ethereum is backed by https://entethalliance.org/. The EEA is a group of about 30 companies that include Accenture, JPMorgan Chase or Intel.


Last added to Crypto Airdrops, Bounties & Opportunities
Name Date How to access Official URL Additional Info
PRIMEDICE 🔥Birthday Crypto Bonus May 12 - May 19 2020 Registered Primedice accounts are getting a VIP bonus every day for the next seven days. This Primedice bonus campaigns is released to the occassion of the 7th birthday of the dice platform. details make acct
OKEx Crypto Signup Bonus Bonus for Signup OKEx, formerly called OKCoin and known as OKCasino, was the BitMEX of 2015 but has fallen out of favour since. They are now running a similar campaign as Coinbase did to get their signup rates up: If you sign up and buy 100 USD worth of BTC, you get 10 USD bonus. details make acct
Cloudbet Turbo Thursday Reload Bonus Every Thursday between 05:00-23:59 UTC Make a deposit of 0.1 mBTC or more today, Cloudbet gives you a 100% Reload Bonus of up to 50 mBTC/1 BCH. Remember you must activate the bonus in your player dashboard before making a deposit for the bonus to be credited! The bonus is only available for the Casino, not the Sportsbook. details make acct
CPD project airdrop to BTC holders At BTC halving block CPD project airdrops tokens at BTC halving to anyone who signups with an ETH address and submits a BTC address that is verified via a signed message. The project aims at creating less monopolized internet environment for innovatiove development. details make acct
Ethermon.io ChainGuardians Discord Airdrop and Signup Bonus April 2020 Ethermon announced on Apr 13 that some of their Mons will be part of a new blockchain RPG game developed by ChainGuardians. There is a discord promo for this launch: On the launch date of the ChainGuardians Official NFT Sale, 150 EMONT will be airdropped to the first 10 people who post a screenshot on Discord fighting a Zedakazm within the ChainGuardians RPG along with proof of purchase (TXID)of any ChainGuardians bundle. The signup bonus is to play ChainGuardians game logged in via an anonymous identity from SafeName.io. You get 100 FREE CGC valued at 0.05 ETH, the link to claim is at the page where you land after confirming your email. Signup at Ethermon Go to Safename.io
Blockstack Free crypto airdrop Jan - Feb 2020 The webwallet blockchain.com is giving away free Stack $STX crypto to their Gold users. The Gold level requires an ID scan and selfie. details make acct
New non-custodial anonymous peer-to-peer Bitcoin trading Opened 19 Nov 2019 If you miss the heyday of LocalBitcoins where anyone could buy BTC locally for cash (which has been banned since this summer) and anonymously (now site-wide KYC is required, plus allegedly LocalBitcoins have been working with three-letter agencies), since 19th November you have the chance to go back in time and buy your corn without ID again - at least for some time. You know that good things like this don't last ... The former ETH marketplace LocalEthereum rebranded to LocalCryptos and offers local and anonymous BTC trading with fully automated escrow that is built natively on BTC blockchain - because bitcoin's smart contract scripting capabilities are good enough for simple stuff like escrows. You can even import your vendor reputation from LocalBitcoins. The reputation import is done via adding a unique code to your LBC profile page, not by linking anything directly, but still in case you like your privacy it's probably only a good idea id you never ID'd on LocalBitcoins. details make acct
Crypto Flowers dApp Game event 12 - 22 Dec 2019 Play the Crypto Flowers TRON version of the dApp game any time between 12 and 22 December to enter the Prize Pool of 100`000 TRX. Just collect and breed flowers and have a chance to win prize pool, no special action needed. details make acct
POOL-X exchange listing promo Daily until listing POL has a random twitter draw of users who post a POOL-X graphic design every day until their token listing on the KuCoin exchange. You need to sign up via Google form and have a KuCoin account. form make acct
Verasity New Triviata Competition November 5 at 00:00 UTC - November 20th 00:00 UTC Verasity is a token-based platform for the attention economy. They always engaged a lot with the community and organized several airdrop and competition campaigns so far. The current two-week campaign relates to the Triviata app (iOS/Android). Sign up and enable your game participation in the app profile, and you get the chance of winning prizes with 4000 USD in total. Even if you don't win though, participating will earn you tokens that can be staked in the official wallet for over 30% yearly earnings. join about
Bethereum Price Pool on VK November 2019 There are regular competitions with the total pool of prizes worth 40K Bether if you join the gaming platform's VK channel. details make acct
Brave New Coin Challenge Until the end of the year The crypto market data provider is giving away small amount of their tokens if you add people to their telegram group. register telegram
FanEspo Big Competition (ERC20) All the time Fanespo is launching a new promotion contest worth $500 in FAN tokens. Details will pop up on you when you sign up on site. Overall, the eSports platform FanEspo is giving away the total of $1.6 million of tokens in contests. You need to have a FanEspo account. details make acct
Atomars Opportunity Launch promo There is a new altcoin axchange launched that now offers zero-fee trading, and possibly thinner markets for the market makers around. details make acct
Keybase Stellar Lumens Drop 11 September 2019 & Onwards The Keybase team announced a surprise airdrop worth 21 USD in XLM to all account holders who ever installed the Keybase app. To get the Lumens, you need to sign in again and claim them - you should have received a bot message with instructions. Keybase has been funded by the Stellar Developer Foundation for years and so this collab is not a one-off. You can choose to keep participating in the Lumens airdrop by using Keybase, the total dollar worth each user can get is 500 USD. New accounts can still participate as long as they have a Github or HackerNews account created before 9 September 2019. more join
BlockWage Airdrops + Bounties Recurring Platform for freelancers marketplace. Airdrops randomly announced via Discord, there's also the possibility of Masternodes. join web
Vaultoro Token Launch Promo September 2019 The crypto-gold exchange Vaultoro has been around for years, getting attention in the 2015 bear market and tagging along through the subsequent bull run. They are now launching their own exchange token which you can get for free if you don't have an account yet. Every new sign up with basic ID verification gets 200 VAULT tokens. homepage make acct