Weekly E-mails:  Crypto Trading Strategy 5 Weeks of Onboarding Reads. Latest Airdrops (Thu 7 AM EST). Or all of it.

Dismiss   Pick Your Preference
This site uses cookies (More).


Economics of Proof of Stake - #CryptoTrading

Proof of stake shows off the extraordinary ability of crypto news portals to write a 500 word article that says absolutely nothing, and the amazing regard of the ETH boss crew to Social Justice.
     · [altcoins]  · Author: KarlVonBahnhof

The gist of PoS

In Proof-of-work (PoW) the longest chain is valid, as in the one with most work. In Proof-of-stake the one that is agreed upon in betting consensus is accepted.

In the proposed version of proof of stake in ETH, stakers make bets on which block will be included in the blockchain. The block that is backed up by most bets is the winning one. The betting is automated and has several rounds as the odds of reaching consensus at each block changes. The initial bets are small, when a leader starts to emerge the bets grow.

The betting happens automatically. All the staker has to do is to put a full node online and lock up their stake for four months. In the last published at least 32 ETH is needed to participate in staking.

Will staking pay off?

If one wants to focus only on profits, staking could be compared to lending at an exchange. Bets made on the winning block get rewarded, the rest is lost. That means there will have to be losses too, but thanks to the system of several betting rounds the losses should be small - the bets start small and move higher once there’s higher confidence regarding the winning block.

It is simply lots of tiny gambles with the odds in the staker’s favor.

There is a counterparty risk as well though: staker loses his lot if it appears that he is engaged in an illicit anti-network activity. This ban from staking is for Vitalik and his crew to judge.

Another small risk comes from volatility of ETH - should a big dump be obvious, staker cannot withdraw his money to sell, but this can be hedged with the help of derivatives.

But practically, staking could be more profitable than lending on an exchange, just probably not for individuals at home as they’d have to run a full node. Running a full node costs energy, maintenance and bandwidth and we all know that even though setting up a parity wallet to make a basic transaction is a matter of an hour max, the full ethereum blockchain has a fat ass.

There probably is an incentive for the ETH fanbois to prefer staking to lending on an exchange though, because as stakers they would be “helping the good cause”.

It seems that Vitalik is aware of these sentiments that are outside of economics, but it is anyone’s guess if he has plans to use them:

Image: From Vitalik’s medium.com post “A Proof of Stake Design Philosophy”

How is it really with the centralization and unfair advantages

The most promoted advantage of proof of stake is that it fights centralization of mining that seems to always emerge in Proof-of-work after some time.

PoW: If you are late to the party or don’t have access to cheap electricity or don’t have enough capital to constantly upgrade your mining equipment, your mining profits will not pay for your expenses - at least not until your coin increases in price, and if you should be waiting for that it would make more sense to simply trade. In addition to this you are fighting mining cartels that might be engaged in selfish mining.

“Selfish Mining”: A group of miners can form a pool that behaves as single agent […] following some strategy. Selfish-Mine allows a pool of sufficient size to obtain a revenue larger than its ratio of mining power.

The key insight behind the selfish mining strategy is to force the honest miners into performing wasted computations on the stale public branch. […] Selfish miners achieve this goal by selectively revealing their mined blocks to invalidate the honest miners’ work. Approximately speaking, the selfish mining pool keeps its mined blocks private, secretly bifurcating the blockchain and creating a private branch. Meanwhile, the honest miners continue mining on the shorter, public branch.

PoS: If ETH main office says you cheat, you lose your stake. If ETH main office says you are honest, you get transaction fees and the block reward. Your profit is proportional to how much you stake, nothing else - there is no difficulty, there will be some hardware maintenance but not as much as with PoW. If you have more starting capital you will earn more, but proportionally more - you are not supposed to get an edge when you have more money.

To put it bluntly, if everything should work as drafted it would mean that the business of staking would not scale the way the business of mining does, but while at the same time staking would not pay off for small individual participants, similarly as with mining of well established coins.

This kind of anti-capitalistic compromise understandably causes some stir, but Vitalik is clearly bigger than that:

Image: via @BitfuryGeorge

And to add to this: it is not even quite clear that Proof-of-stake is really free from all this unfairness.

What’s not clear

  • Staker A owns 100 ETH and stakes all 100 of it. Staker B owns 100 000 ETH and stakes all of it but into 1000 different accounts. Has Staker B has 1000x chance to find the block over Staker A?
  • What if all the stakers are the same staker? How would anyone know?

The answers to this would probably be that this is an attack, there might be a fork - you know the drill. It is unclear how would this be detected.

  • If a staker-attacker has an ETH short equal or more than his stake and is the majority network validator, then the staker-attacker has nothing to lose. The currency will lose in value but the staker-attacker has the short to profit from the drop.

While there is an argument that it is not possible to short this much ETH on any exchange, it might be possible in the future if there are more highly leveraged futures or option markets available. One could also long Alt/ETH pairs.

  • The “nothing at stake” problem: In the case of a consensus failure stakers have nothing to lose by voting for multiple blockchain-histories, which prevents the consensus from ever resolving. Because there is little cost in working on several chains (unlike in proof-of-work systems), anyone can abuse this problem “for free”.

In one Ethereum implementation called slasher, this behavior would fall under “cheating” and would lead to the loss of the stake, but slasher introduces other problems - what if most staking nodes drop out (blockchain generation freezes, called “ice age”) and what if there is no consensus (blockchain generation gets stuck). You can read the whole mildly technical explanation at ethereum’s github. Casper should work with some form of slashing conditions.

In the Ethereum roadmap, the switch to Proof-of-stake is planned for June 2018 (the switch has been postponed several times). At this stage, of course Proof-of-stake in ETH is not ready yet, but what is the hype all about, really?

PoS is not convenient for big miners, it is not convenient for hobby miners/stakers, it is not convenient for traders & holders because it introduces new possible problems and reasons for forks - but it’s the next big thing because it is a system that is “more fair” and also “eco friendly”? Quite serious there?

Frankly it does not really scream advantages, other than what relates to “Vitalik philosophy”:

Image: From Vitalik’s medium.com post “A Proof of Stake Design Philosophy”


Update, 13 Jul ‘17

Tuur Demeester published critique of Vitalik’s piece on the PoS.

Vitalik’s response and discussion here


Last added to Crypto Airdrops, Bounties & Opportunities
Name Date How to access Official URL Additional Info
PRIMEDICE 🔥Birthday Crypto Bonus May 12 - May 19 2020 Registered Primedice accounts are getting a VIP bonus every day for the next seven days. This Primedice bonus campaigns is released to the occassion of the 7th birthday of the dice platform. details make acct
OKEx Crypto Signup Bonus Bonus for Signup OKEx, formerly called OKCoin and known as OKCasino, was the BitMEX of 2015 but has fallen out of favour since. They are now running a similar campaign as Coinbase did to get their signup rates up: If you sign up and buy 100 USD worth of BTC, you get 10 USD bonus. details make acct
Cloudbet Turbo Thursday Reload Bonus Every Thursday between 05:00-23:59 UTC Make a deposit of 0.1 mBTC or more today, Cloudbet gives you a 100% Reload Bonus of up to 50 mBTC/1 BCH. Remember you must activate the bonus in your player dashboard before making a deposit for the bonus to be credited! The bonus is only available for the Casino, not the Sportsbook. details make acct
CPD project airdrop to BTC holders At BTC halving block CPD project airdrops tokens at BTC halving to anyone who signups with an ETH address and submits a BTC address that is verified via a signed message. The project aims at creating less monopolized internet environment for innovatiove development. details make acct
Ethermon.io ChainGuardians Discord Airdrop and Signup Bonus April 2020 Ethermon announced on Apr 13 that some of their Mons will be part of a new blockchain RPG game developed by ChainGuardians. There is a discord promo for this launch: On the launch date of the ChainGuardians Official NFT Sale, 150 EMONT will be airdropped to the first 10 people who post a screenshot on Discord fighting a Zedakazm within the ChainGuardians RPG along with proof of purchase (TXID)of any ChainGuardians bundle. The signup bonus is to play ChainGuardians game logged in via an anonymous identity from SafeName.io. You get 100 FREE CGC valued at 0.05 ETH, the link to claim is at the page where you land after confirming your email. Signup at Ethermon Go to Safename.io
Blockstack Free crypto airdrop Jan - Feb 2020 The webwallet blockchain.com is giving away free Stack $STX crypto to their Gold users. The Gold level requires an ID scan and selfie. details make acct
New non-custodial anonymous peer-to-peer Bitcoin trading Opened 19 Nov 2019 If you miss the heyday of LocalBitcoins where anyone could buy BTC locally for cash (which has been banned since this summer) and anonymously (now site-wide KYC is required, plus allegedly LocalBitcoins have been working with three-letter agencies), since 19th November you have the chance to go back in time and buy your corn without ID again - at least for some time. You know that good things like this don't last ... The former ETH marketplace LocalEthereum rebranded to LocalCryptos and offers local and anonymous BTC trading with fully automated escrow that is built natively on BTC blockchain - because bitcoin's smart contract scripting capabilities are good enough for simple stuff like escrows. You can even import your vendor reputation from LocalBitcoins. The reputation import is done via adding a unique code to your LBC profile page, not by linking anything directly, but still in case you like your privacy it's probably only a good idea id you never ID'd on LocalBitcoins. details make acct
Crypto Flowers dApp Game event 12 - 22 Dec 2019 Play the Crypto Flowers TRON version of the dApp game any time between 12 and 22 December to enter the Prize Pool of 100`000 TRX. Just collect and breed flowers and have a chance to win prize pool, no special action needed. details make acct
POOL-X exchange listing promo Daily until listing POL has a random twitter draw of users who post a POOL-X graphic design every day until their token listing on the KuCoin exchange. You need to sign up via Google form and have a KuCoin account. form make acct
Verasity New Triviata Competition November 5 at 00:00 UTC - November 20th 00:00 UTC Verasity is a token-based platform for the attention economy. They always engaged a lot with the community and organized several airdrop and competition campaigns so far. The current two-week campaign relates to the Triviata app (iOS/Android). Sign up and enable your game participation in the app profile, and you get the chance of winning prizes with 4000 USD in total. Even if you don't win though, participating will earn you tokens that can be staked in the official wallet for over 30% yearly earnings. join about
Bethereum Price Pool on VK November 2019 There are regular competitions with the total pool of prizes worth 40K Bether if you join the gaming platform's VK channel. details make acct
Brave New Coin Challenge Until the end of the year The crypto market data provider is giving away small amount of their tokens if you add people to their telegram group. register telegram
FanEspo Big Competition (ERC20) All the time Fanespo is launching a new promotion contest worth $500 in FAN tokens. Details will pop up on you when you sign up on site. Overall, the eSports platform FanEspo is giving away the total of $1.6 million of tokens in contests. You need to have a FanEspo account. details make acct
Atomars Opportunity Launch promo There is a new altcoin axchange launched that now offers zero-fee trading, and possibly thinner markets for the market makers around. details make acct
Keybase Stellar Lumens Drop 11 September 2019 & Onwards The Keybase team announced a surprise airdrop worth 21 USD in XLM to all account holders who ever installed the Keybase app. To get the Lumens, you need to sign in again and claim them - you should have received a bot message with instructions. Keybase has been funded by the Stellar Developer Foundation for years and so this collab is not a one-off. You can choose to keep participating in the Lumens airdrop by using Keybase, the total dollar worth each user can get is 500 USD. New accounts can still participate as long as they have a Github or HackerNews account created before 9 September 2019. more join
BlockWage Airdrops + Bounties Recurring Platform for freelancers marketplace. Airdrops randomly announced via Discord, there's also the possibility of Masternodes. join web
Vaultoro Token Launch Promo September 2019 The crypto-gold exchange Vaultoro has been around for years, getting attention in the 2015 bear market and tagging along through the subsequent bull run. They are now launching their own exchange token which you can get for free if you don't have an account yet. Every new sign up with basic ID verification gets 200 VAULT tokens. homepage make acct